• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • About
  • Bars
    • Bar Reviews
    • Bar Quest
  • Cocktails
    • Cocktail Recipes
    • Home Bar
  • Contact
  • Archives

Slightly Pretentious

Great Cocktails. Spectacular Stays. Only Slightly Pretentious.

Fish House Punch Recipe: Does it Get Much Better than This? I’m Not Sure it Does…

September 14, 2020 by Sean 2 Comments

Fish House Punch Cocktail
Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

There are a lot of delicious drinks out there that should get more play, but maybe none more so than the Fish House Punch.

My first experience with making a Fish House Punch came from the original Dead Rabbit cocktail book. On my first visit to the bar, I had a drink called a Bankers Punch which immediately became one of my favorite drinks.

Since most of the drinks in the books were so complex, I thumbed through the pages trying to find something that seemed doable, and their Philadelphia Fish House Punch recipe was the first one I found that seemed manageable (this being a relative term).

It uses many of the same rums I already had, but the difficult part was making your own oleo saccharum. An oleo saccharum is a process of combining the oils of citrus peels with sugar in order to extract more flavor out of the fruit.

It took some time to make, but the result was fantastic. And is something I’ve made for parties multiple times.

It’s boozier than you expect it to be, has a nice peach flavor from the peach liqueur, and the nutmeg grated over the drink really puts it over the top.

But for the Dead Rabbit version, it takes some time to make. Once you have the syrup/oleo saccharum made, you can cut the recipe down by 1/10ths to make one offs, but it still isn’t a drink you just whip together.

A Simple Fish House Punch Recipe

About a year later, I was reading through the Cocktail Codex book (our pick for the best cocktail book, if you haven’t seen that post yet), and found another recipe for a Fish House Punch.

It was quite a bit different than the Dead Rabbit version using fewer rums, adding cognac, and not having to create a time consuming syrup.

So obviously, it can’t be as good, right?

Wrong.

Upon making the Fish House Punch for the first time I found the drink to be wonderful. It feels less boozy than the Dead Rabbit version (which needs an hour or so on ice in a punchbowl to help dilute), but still retained that wonderful marriage of citrus and peach that makes the drink so good. Oh, and let’s not forget the nutmeg is still there.

Fish House Punch Cocktail-4
Maybe it’s just me, but anything with fresh nutmeg over the top? I’m probably going to like it.

Neither of these versions is better than the other, but certainly a bit different. But to have one that only takes 5 minutes to make, and is broadly approachable for basically any guest that comes over – that’s a win in my book.

This summer, I’ve probably served the Fish House Punch more than any other drink at my (socially distanced) gatherings on the back deck, and it will continue to be a favorite for many years to come.

One of the things I’ve found about this drink, is it’s pretty flexible. So close counts with ingredients.

I’ve made it with regular Plantation white rum, Havana Club 7 year, and my normal go to Banks 7. They all work.

I’ve made it with (cringe) bottle lemon juice in a pinch – still tastes great!

One big non-negotiable for having this drink turn out correctly those is the Creme de Peche. It’s one of the dominant flavors in a Fish House Punch, so without it, you’re going to end up with a different cocktail.

Although, I do wonder how it would taste with apricot….hmmmmm.

You can also use regular or demerara simple syrup, but we prefer the latter for this one. Here’s how to make simple syrup on your own (and save a ton of money).

All that to say, if you’re looking for a drink that will satisfy both those that want something sweet and easy to drink, but also those looking for something more complex and worthy of a cocktail connoisseur, then look no further than this Fish House Punch recipe. There are lots of variations out there, so do some research and try different types if it’s a drink that appeals to you. But even if you go no further than this recipe here, you’ll still be in really good shape.

Be sure to buy the Cocktail Codex book for more easy to make recipes, and if you’re the adventurous type who wants to get more involved in your cocktails? Then the Dead Rabbit Drinks Manual is an excellent addition to your library as well.

Fish House Punch Cocktail

Fish House Punch Recipe (Make in 5 Minutes!)

This is one of the easiest and fastest Fish House Punch recipes I've found. Oh, and it's delicious.
Print Recipe
CourseDrinks
CuisineAmerican
Keywordscocktail codex, dead rabbit, fish house punch, punch, rum
GlassRocks
DifficultyEasy
Total Time5 minutes
Servings1 Drink
Calories210kcal
Cost$3

Equipment

  • Cocktail Shaker
  • Hawthorne Strainer
  • Chinois

Ingredients

  • 2 oz Cold Club Soda
  • .75 oz Cognac
  • .75 oz Blended Aged Rum I use Banks 7 (but there are plenty of cheaper options that will yield similar results)
  • .75 oz Creme de Peche
  • .75 oz Fresh Lemon Juice
  • .25 oz Demerara Syrup Regular simple syrup will totally work
  • 1 Sprinkle Nutmeg Fresh is best, but bottled is great.

Instructions

  • Combine all ingredients except nutmeg into cocktail shaker
  • Shake for 10 seconds
  • Double strain over large cube
  • Sprinkle or grate fresh nutmeg over the top

Nutrition

Calories: 210kcal

Resources Mentioned in This Post

Best Overall Cocktail Book
Cocktail Codex: Fundamentals, Formulas, Evolutions
Cocktail Codex: Fundamentals, Formulas, Evolutions
$22.49

There's a reason this is our favorite cocktail book for most people. Not only does it have delicious recipes, but it shows you how to come up with great drinks of your own, without being overly technical.

Buy it on Amazon Here
03/20/2023 07:39 am GMT
The Dead Rabbit Drinks Manual: Secret Recipes and Barroom Tales
The Dead Rabbit Drinks Manual: Secret Recipes and Barroom Tales
$17.99

The drinks in this book are a little more advanced, but if you're up for a challenge you'll be WELL rewarded. Do yourself a favor, start with the "Bankers Punch"

Buy Now on Amazon
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
03/20/2023 07:16 am GMT

Additional Recipes You Might Enjoy

If you liked this Fish House Punch, you may also enjoy these drinks:

  • Peach Old Fashioned – Creme de Peche is a “secret weapon ingredient” that can be a great tasting spin on many classics
  • Avocado Margarita – Another great patio drink, and one of the best ones I’ve ever created.
  • Repossession Cocktail – Another lemon sour drink, made more unique by using sherry and mezcal from the NoMad team.

Filed Under: Cocktail Recipes Tagged With: cocktail codex, punch, rum

About Sean

Sean has spent the last decade teaching people how to build small businesses, playing golf, and sneaking into high class establishments where he probably doesn't belong. Slightly pretentious is a tongue in cheek description of his travels.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Jenn says

    September 16, 2020 at 2:32 pm

    I literally just peeled my way through setting up my first attempt at oleo saccharum. I’ll have to look for the OG Bankers Punch recipe. Thanks for the tip!

    Reply
    • Sean says

      September 21, 2020 at 11:00 am

      ha it’s a lot of peeling! Thats why the Cocktail Codex version was so appealing – much less of a process. But the Bankers Punch may be my favorite cocktail of all time – so it’s worth doing!

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

ABOUT SLIGHTLY PRETENTIOUS

At Slightly Pretentious we're on a quest to visit the top 100 bars in the world, and here we share stories from those travels while also helping you create killer cocktails at home.

Let's face it, if you're into bougie cocktails? There's at least a small part of you that is slightly pretentious. This is a safe space to embrace it :)

FREE GUIDE: How to Build the Ultimate Home Bar

Want to make world class cocktails at home? Here's everything you need to know to create the ultimate home bar - at any budget.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Home Bar Resources

best home ice makers

5 of the Best Home Ice Makers to Buy in 2023

December 10, 2022 By Sean Leave a Comment

Smoke Boards: What's in the Box

Best Cocktail Smoker: Smoke Boards is My New Favorite Drink Smoker

December 9, 2022 By Sean 2 Comments

25+ Best Cocktail Gifts Ideas for the 2022 Holiday Season

December 2, 2022 By Sean 4 Comments

Best Bars in the World

NoMad Bar NYC

NoMad Bar NYC: A Must Visit Bar in New York City

March 1, 2019 By Sean

Cocktail at Nottingham Forest in Milan

Nottingham Forest: A Sensory Cocktail Experience in Milan

March 5, 2019 By Sean

Connaught Bar London

Connaught Bar London: The Fanciest Bar I’ve Ever Been To

March 28, 2019 By Sean

Cocktail Recipes

Morgenthaler’s Sherry Eggnog: The World’s Best Eggnog Recipe. Period.

December 12, 2022 By Sean

Funky Rum Negroni

How to Make a Rum Negroni: The Artsy Bird is a Funky Rum Cocktail

December 7, 2022 By Sean

Bees Knees Cocktail

Bees Knees Cocktail: A Fantastic Introduction to Gin Cocktails

December 5, 2022 By Sean

Latest Reviews

  • Regarding Cocktails: A Cocktail Book Where Simplicity Shines
    9.1
  • NoMad Cocktail Book Review: For the Adventurous Home Bartender
    9.3
  • Mixology Masterclass Review: Is Mr. Lyan’s Cocktail Course Worth It?
    9.3

SEARCH THE SITE

Footer

  • About: What is the Deal with Slightly Pretentious?
  • Contact
  • Archives
  • Top 100 Bars
  • Privacy Policy

Recent

  • Naked and Famous Cocktail: A Wonderful Last Word Riff from Death and Co
  • Double Chicken Please: Is it Really Top 10 In the World?
  • Morgenthaler’s Sherry Eggnog: The World’s Best Eggnog Recipe. Period.
  • 5 of the Best Home Ice Makers to Buy in 2023
  • Islay Scotch: The Ultimate Guide to Visiting Islay, Scotland

Search

Tags

50 best bars americano boulevardier bourbon campari canon cocktail codex creme de violette cuba eggnog gin green chartreuse Italy lemon lime london manhattan maraschino liqueur margarita martini masterclass matsuhisa mezcal mojito moscow mule mr lyan negroni nomad bar non alcoholic NYC old fashioned paris punch rum rye sazerac sherry Singapore strawberry tequila Tokyo Top 100 Bars union club vail vodka

Copyright © 2023 · Location 180, LLC | Privacy Policy